2007 ALCS News: Drew out, Kielty in for GM 1; Wake on for GM4

Due to the relative success Bobby Kielty (.310, 9-29, 2HRs) has had against Indians ace C.C. Sabathia and the brief-yet-unsuccessful showing J.D. Drew (0-3, 3Ks) has had against the hefty Cleveland lefty, Drew will be on the Boston bench when the ALCS kicks off tomorrow night at Fenway.

Many people will applaud this move, mainly due to the fact that Drew has been a colossal bust in the first year of his mega deal with the Sox and has been the whipping boy for the Nation, so I am in the minority here in thinking that this move could be one of the few that have come back to bite Francona in the ass this season.

For one thing Drew had finally started to put it together at the end of the season, batting .342 (26-76) in September with 4 homers and 18 RBIs in the month, while Kielty had a whopping 4 hits in 26 at bats (.154) in the final month.

Granted he's hitting .260 vs. lefties this season compared to Drew's .224, but Drew had 26 hits in 116 at bats vs. southpaws this season, while Kielty had 13 hits in 50 at bats; not exactly a staggering enough difference in statistics to warrant such a move.

Throw in the fact that despite his offensive woes Drew has proven to be one of the best right fielders in the league, coupled with the importance of defense during the playoffs, especially in Fenway's tricky right field, and the move seems even more odd.

As has been the case for most of the season, I hope Tito is right with this hunch. But to replace a season-long starter and above-average fielder in the first game of the biggest series of the season for a part-timer who has had slightly more success than the incumbent seems to me like a risky move at a time the team cannot afford to take too many gambles.

Who knows, maybe this hunch will prove to be golden, just like his decision to stick with Dustin Pedroia and utilizing some of his cockamamie batting orders did. But if Kielty doesn't get a couple of hits off Sabathia, or fails to make a key play in the outfield, Tito will experience the full wrath of the Nation for making a questionable decision at the worst possible time of the year.

Wake healthy and ready to go for Game 4
The back and shoulder injuries that have been nagging at Tim Wakefield over the last few weeks have finally dissipated enough to allow the team to add him to the ALCS roster, and the knuckleballer said he has every intention of taking the mound for Game 4 in Cleveland next Tuesday.

The return of the 17-game winner and grizzled playoff vet can only help a team that has already had brilliant performances turned in by two of its starters, and the great part about old rubber arm is that he would be able to pitch out of the bullpen in Game 6 or 7 if necessary, although after what happened in the 2003 ALCS, the team may be leery of soing so.

Still, there is nothing wrong with having too much pitching, as Boston has proven all year, and the addition of wake gives some insurance that should Daisuke Matsuzaka falter in Game 3 (as many expect), the Sox wouldn't have to bring Beckett back on short rest to pitch a Game 5.

The return of Wakefield gives Boston a trio of playoff vets who together have made 39 postseason appearances and have a combined record of 19-9 in fall baseball, along with an inexperienced yet talented rookie who could either throw a no-hitter or shit the bed.

Compare that to the inexperienced Cleveland starters Sabathia, Fausto Carmona, Jake Westbrook and Paul Byrd, who have made a grand total of 10 appearances with a record of 4-2 in October, and I like the Sox chances of taking this series even better than before.

Just as long as the tribe didn't re-sign Aaron Bleepin Boone before the end of the season and try to sneak him onto the roster.

Bring it on, bitches!